Tuesday, May 29, 2007

Another string of reviews of fantasy

This time by Kajsa Öberg-Lindsten in the newspaper GP.

Two Swedish original novels and three translations. It is a bit peculiar how the reviewer sees five male protagonists out of five possible as a way to adapt to the market.

Had it been Science Fiction I might have understood the idea, but claiming that the authors need to adapt their fantasy novels to a male readership is more than slightly peculiar considering the vast amount of female readers of that genre.

A set of choppy reviews is ended by politicising feminist roles versus male ones. We have the usual rant about all men depicted as knights in shining armour and all women as stupid, goodlooking or motherly, submissive wenches.

In the end the review itself manages to become more stereotyped and clichéd than genre fantasy has ever been accused of.

No comments: